Righty proved wrong (Chris Fryer 1, James Ozark 0)
Sunday, January 30th, 2005Update: Ken Parish has kindly pointed out that I was wrong about the US Supreme Court ruling in 1944. It appears there were two rulings in December about the detainment of citizens of Japanese ancestry.
Korematsu v. United States. In this case it was decided 6-3 that the exclusion of Japanese Americans from the west coast was constitutional.
Ex Parte Endo. In this case, the Supreme Court decided unanimously that Mitsuye Endo should be released from custody, as her loyalty was clearly apparent.
After this ruling major Pratt, commander of Military Area 1 suspended the exclusion order and Japanese Americans were able to return to home.
–End Update–
Every blogger should know by now that Mamdouh Habib has been released from prison in Guantanamo Bay and returned to Australia via charted jet. This has caused howls of indignation from the right and applause from the left.
There has been a particularly nasty post on AWH by blogger Paul Bickford. It wasn’t this post that got me angry, but what I read in the comments.
“I suspect given what we know about him and his associations, that he was very likely guilty of just about everything the yanks were holding him for. – James Ozark”
This prompted a response by blogger Liam Hogan.
“I don’t know about you lot but I don’t look forward to the day when Australian citizens can be sent to prison for ‘associations’. – Liam Hogan”
I know this is getting pretty boring but its about to get funny.
“Don’t look forward to the day? Better hit those good old history books, then, buddy. During WWII, people were imprisoned for *exactly* that. It’s called war. – James Ozark”
This got me quite angry not only were people imprisoned for no reason other than their country of origin, but there are some people who think that this policy was the right thing to do.
I’m not alone in thinking this was wrong, I did a little research and what do you know in 1944 the US Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the detainment of Japanese Americans during WW2 was unconstitutional.
James obviously doesn’t know anything about history (or Google or Wikipedia) because you should read what he wrote next.
“Oh yeah, and horror of horrors, democracy and elections were suspended for the duration of the war, too, as they were in every Western democracy. – James Ozark”
In every Western democracy? What alternate reality are you living in James. Because in this reality, the US didn’t suspend their elections, and they?re a western democracy aren’t they. There were democracies, such as the UK, that did suspend their elections, but remember he said every western democracy.
James when you make such bold statements about history you better make sure they are correct (I was going to write “right” but I think that’s the cause of his problem).








